When a Hospital Closes-Nobody Wins [PODCAST]
When a Hospital Closes, Nobody Wins
In this episode, Dr. Wael Khouli, Physician Executive and former Chief Medical Officer, and Gretchen Heinen, CEO and Founder of Authsnap, Inc., discusses “When a hospital closes, nobody wins.”
Highlights of this episode include:
- When a hospital closes, it’s more than a business failure
- Who feels the impact first when a hospital closes
- The ripple effect throughout a community
- How rural communities are significantly impacted by closures
- Warning signs healthcare leaders and policymakers should pay attention to before a closure
- What happens to patient care when a community loses its local hospital
- What to change to help hospitals remain financially viable while improving patient care
- Who loses the most and what can healthcare leaders do today to prevent more closures tomorrow
- What most people misunderstand about why hospital struggles financially
Subscribe Today!
Kelly Wisness: Hi, this is Kelly Wisness. Welcome back to the award-winning Hospital Finance Podcast. We’re pleased to welcome Dr. Wael Khoul and Gretchen Heinen. Gretchen is the CEO and founder of Authsnap, Inc. She’s a registered nurse with over a decade of frontline clinical experience in emergency and case management settings, and she co-founded Authsnap after watching patients lose access to care they needed, while also watching colleagues burn out fighting paperwork that was never supposed to be theirs. She has been featured in Medical Economics, MSU Foundation, The Nursing Site, and The Authority Business Show.
Dr. Khouli is a physician executive and former chief medical officer who has spent over two decades at the intersection of clinical medicine and hospital operations. He co-founded Authsnap, Inc., an AI-powered platform that fights insurance denials for hospitals and health systems, and recently presented at the NPAC 2026 on responsible AI adoption and physician advisory. He has been published in Medical Economics, HIT Consultant, Electronic Health Reporter, and Authority Magazine.
In this episode, we’re discussing “When a hospital closes, nobody wins.” Welcome, and thank you for joining us, Gretchen and Wael.
Dr. Wael Khouli: Thank you for having us.
Gretchen Heinen: Thank you, Kelly.
Kelly: All right, well, let’s go ahead and jump in. So, when people hear that a hospital is closing, they often think it’s a business failure. Why is the reality much more complicated than that?
Gretchen: Yeah, a hospital closure is a much more complicated story than many of the businesses that we could think of where it’s a badly run business resulted in its failure. Many of the realities and the challenges are unique to hospitals and health systems. For example, there is a limited, steady fixed reimbursement, while everything else is not static. Even changes in the insurance payer mix can make huge differences, and those could happen without any notice, without gradually changing the landscape there. For example, Medicare Advantage used to be a minority of Medicare. Now, it’s more than half. So, a hospital is dealing with a large number of payers instead of one, and each one has its own process and different way of reimbursing and denying and different patterns and so on. Now, if you go to the cost side, the cost is changing, even if the reimbursement and the pay is the same. Labor cost has increased tremendously since the pandemic, basically. We’re all familiar with all the supply chain challenges that are happening and the geopolitical factors. Also, they don’t have any impact on it. The staffing challenges. So many, many factors that contribute to the hospital’s financial well-being that are very challenging to manage.
Kelly: Yeah, I know we’ve been hearing a lot about hospital closures lately. I know this is a very pressing issue. So, who feels the impact first when a hospital closes? And what are the ripple effects throughout a community?
Gretchen: Of course, the community is going to be the first one that sees that, especially if you think of rural communities. And those are the hospitals that are at the most risk and the most financially challenged. I live in a rural community myself in northern Michigan, and the next hospital that’s similar to the size of the one in my town, for example, is three and a half hours away. So, it’s definitely the patients who are going to suffer first. Some of the services that need to be emergent, you’re actually, completely unfortunately out of luck there. If you have a stroke, a myocardial infarction, you’ve already lost multiple hours when a hospital closes. You’ll see sometimes shutdown in service lines in smaller hospitals that I’m familiar with, actually, myself personally, who had to move on from OB. So, the mother has to have a significantly long drive before getting to the next place to deliver.
Kelly: Yeah, I know these rural communities have been significantly impacted by the closures. You’ve spent years working with insurance authorizations and denials. How much do payer-related delays, denials, and administrative burdens contribute to financial pressure on hospitals?
Dr. Khouli: I can speak a little bit about this one, Kelly. So, there’s a lot of numbers that are factored into that and because you mentioned a few different buckets there. But just specifically denials, I mean, the last really published reported figure is from several years ago that there’s $262 billion worth of denied claims, so it’s probably much higher. But the biggest problem with measuring the amount of denials happening, especially if we’re talking denials, is that there’s really not a forced reporting mechanism for the payers on how much is being denied, so it’s really anecdotal or survey-based whenever we’re getting these numbers. And I know from our experience with working with the customers that we have, it’s sometimes much higher and bigger of a problem than even the industry statistics. About between 10 and 20% of claims will get denied, depending on how efficient the hospital system is at managing that type of work. And each claim, especially for pretty much any size hospital, but depending on what the situation is for the patient, whether it’s a sepsis, DRG downgrade, or if it’s an inpatient versus observation status, so a medical necessity denial, those can be anywhere between a few thousand dollars to $10, 000. I mean, we’ve seen such a range in the amount that gets reimbursed or paid back to the hospital for each of those scenarios. And now you times that by thousands of patients, you can see why this becomes such a challenge, particularly for denied claims. Wael, do you want to share more about that?
Gretchen: Many times, these are flying under the radar that they’re not even accounted for. Could be as simple as a claim, a request from the payer to change the code or to downgrade to a different DRG, and it may happen in the background with significant, significant impact there. And that is actually represents another challenge for rural hospitals. Large health systems, regional, national health systems can manage having 20, 30 different payers, with each one has different processes and policies and portal to submit the communication. But when you’re a rural hospital, it’s often one person who not only doing denials for multiple payers, but they actually all have other hats that they…other responsibilities. So, makes it even more impactful, more consequential for smaller hospitals.
Kelly: No, I bet. And I know denials are a huge issue and, like you said, probably bigger than we even know. So many rural and community hospitals are struggling right now. What warning signs should healthcare leaders and policymakers pay [attention?] to before a closure becomes inevitable?
Gretchen: So, from the policymaking standpoint, I mean, listening to the people– I mean, that’s the first thing that they should investigate and hear from their constituents about the access, about access to healthcare, especially in rural communities. So, I mean, the signs of people movement, actually, because of the lack of healthcare, the loss of the workforce. Often, that could be related also to healthcare. And, of course, the numbers are available to each state. And the margins of the hospitals, the nonprofit hospitals, those are all reportable. And you could see the challenges that they’re facing. The workforce’s challenging. So of course, at the end, it’s going to be a shutdown. And before that, you see the service lines that are being eliminated. One of the areas that are very prominent in rural communities, for example, is mental health. Because the reimbursement model is so outdated, let’s say, and disproportionate while the regulatory requirements are so tight, many hospitals have moved on from providing psychiatric inpatient care, for example. And even mental health at outpatient on intermediate level are very limited. And you hear the stories, for example, in rural communities where a patient is in the ED for multiple days before being transported eight hours to a large city to be hospitalized. And I know policymakers, they are aware of these challenges and they need to pay more attention to them.
Kelly: Yeah, I mean, those are some significant challenges. And thank you for sharing those warning signs with us. So, what happens to patient care when a community loses its local hospital?
Dr. Khouli: Well, you’re going to start seeing sicker patients. It’s very similar to what happened with COVID where we didn’t have as much access. And so people’s chronic conditions are going to go more unmanaged, and then they’re going to be sicker when they do end up getting the care. So, a good example of something I witnessed a lot in the time I was working in rural health is people with diabetes would really go unmanaged because they didn’t want to drive the hour and a half or, as Wael mentioned, the three hours to go get their A1C checked or really stay compliant with their medication if they had type 2 diabetes. So, their chronic conditions just get worse and worse, and then they are sicker and sicker when they have to go really far, especially when there’s aging population. They’re even more resistant to traveling far different distances with their chronic conditions. So, I think you just end up getting a sicker population, and you’re also going to lose jobs for that community. So, if the hospital closes, a lot of times those are a major source of jobs for that community. So entire towns can die when we don’t have some of these critical access or rural healthcare pockets across the country.
And in a bigger example, we see a lot of times these really struggling hospitals getting swallowed up by bigger hospitals. We just had one happen here in the Twin Cities recently. And that changes a lot because it’s just like any other business. When you take over a business, there’s a huge change in the jobs. It’s a huge change in how they manage it. Now, some of that stuff that was being handled at the hospital here, now that they’re owned by an entity out of state, some of that centralized stuff is happening at the parent company, and they don’t need as many of those jobs. So, it’s really a combination of people getting sicker and an effect on the economy.
Kelly: That all makes a lot of sense to me. I mean, having that sicker community, that’s a very big deal. If you could change one thing about the healthcare system to help hospitals remain financially viable while improving patient care, what would it be?
Gretchen: If I have a magic wand looking at the complexity of our healthcare system, it’s having one standard, one way to send claims and get reimbursement, and overall standards for disease and payment and denials. Just one portal. I remember a former colleague of mine, she was Canadian, and she said that she was from Ontario and said that there is one building in London, Ontario, that manages all healthcare for the whole province, basically, because they’re universal.
Of course, I mean, I’m not saying that that’s what we need, but just imagine that even if our health systems, there is the competition that we have, there are the healthy elements that we have in our health systems, and the fragmented insurance landscape, but we have one standard for reimbursement and payment.
Kelly: Yeah, it’s a very interesting perspective. Thank you for sharing that with us. The title of this episode is “When a Hospital Closes, Nobody Wins.” So, who loses the most, and what can healthcare leaders do today to prevent more closures tomorrow?
Dr. Khouli: Well, I think the biggest thing for, and we’ve touched on the loss of the patients and the residents and the community quite a bit. But one thing that we’re not really, I think, giving enough light to is the fact that if you can really get your hospital financially healthy by dealing with your underpayments, dealing with your denials, making sure your coding and billing team knows what they’re doing, that’s a real challenge in some of these rural communities is there’s people who have been occupying that role for 20 or 30 years. They’ve had the same CFO for a long time, they’ve had the same billers and coders.
And it’s a challenge for those communities to really be able to keep that workforce totally up to date with all of the ever-changing rules that happen in the payer landscape. I mean, Wael and I do this professionally as a business, and even I read things every day that I’m like, “Oh, I didn’t know that that was happening,” or, “Oh, there’s a new ruling.” Or for example, in January, 632 different surgeries are falling off of the inpatient-only list. A rural hospital might not really be keeping up with what’s happening at CMS. That person is trying, Wael mentioned, they’re trying to do multiple jobs.
One person is trying to do both coding and billing and CDI. Sometimes we’ve seen situations where the CFO is the one writing the appeal letters. They are literally just trying to grab anybody who has a spare second to deal with the financial difficulties of their situation. And so, in my opinion, and kind of our stance at Authsnap is, get yourself financially healthy. And you can do that by making sure that your team really understands how the payer landscape works. You’re bringing in the right partners who are going to help you with all of those. You know, you’re making sure that your team is upskilled and they’re refreshed, and they understand all the rules.
There’s continuing education, which is a challenge. If you’re working so many jobs, they’re not likely to send you to a conference, right? So, there are things that these hospitals can do to partner with the right people to start over the financial health of the hospital, and that’s going to help them keep their doors open and stay healthy.
Kelly: Yeah. No. That’s great. Thank you for sharing that with us. You’ve worked on both the clinical and business sides of healthcare. What’s something that most people misunderstand about why hospitals struggle financially?
Dr. Khouli: Yeah. I often use an example of the payment model from a business cash flow perspective. You could think of Amazon, right, from when it started. Amazon gets paid by the customer, and then the cost comes in when they buy the book, right, or now the other merchandise. So, hospitals are the other way around. They have to spend a significant amount of resources, have very high fixed costs, basically. You need significant regulatory requirement. And those are not easy to maintain, and they’re expensive. So, it is so expensive to have the infrastructure, to have the team, and then one patient at a time. You’re putting the expense, and then you’re waiting for the reimbursement to come back. And that’s not accounting for all the hurdles that you have getting your reimbursement, including the denials and prior authorizations. And, of course, the staffing challenges, the changes in the reimbursement models, the changes in the insurance marketplace there. All these things are difficult for hospitals to adjust to.
Kelly: Most definitely. Thank you for that, Wael. And thank you both for joining us and sharing your insights with us on, When a Hospital Closes, Nobody Wins. And if a listener wants to learn more or contact you to discuss this topic further, how best can they do that?
Dr. Khouli: Yeah. So we have a pretty active LinkedIn. If you type in Authsnap, like, “Authorization and a snap,” right? So authsnap.ai. That’s our website, but we’re active on LinkedIn. You can go to our website. We even have a tool on our website where you can see how denials are impacting you, impacting your facility, and you can kind of see what could be on the table for you that you might be leaving on the table dollar-wise. Otherwise, our email is info@authsnap.ai, and we’d love to have a conversation with your listeners.
Kelly: Great. Thank you for providing that. And thank you all for joining us for this episode of The Hospital Finance Podcast. Until next time…
[music] This concludes our episode of The Hospital Finance Podcast. For show notes and additional resources, visit us online at besler.holdings. The Hospital Finance Podcast is a production of Besler Holdings; Built on partnership, Driven by success.
If you have a topic that you’d like us to discuss on The Hospital Finance Podcast or if you’d like to be a guest, drop us a line at contact@besler.holdings.






